Indulge in Cheesy Au Gratin Potatoes – The Best Thanksgiving Treat!

Cheesy Au Gratin Potatoes on the Thanksgiving table… let’s be honest, they steal the show every single time. You know that panic when your turkey’s taking its sweet time and there’s hungry family crowding the kitchen? A bubbling dish of cheesy au gratin potatoes can shut everybody up (and that’s saying something). Seriously, I’ve even caught my little cousin sneaking seconds before the ham got carved. If you’ve never tried making this, trust me, it’s way easier than it looks. And if you’re already in the potato-obsessed club, try pairing them with this Authentic Spicy Potatoes or even these spooky-good Cheesy Pizza Skulls That’ll Haunt Your Taste Buds. Yeah, I know, I’m shameless about potatoes.

Everything you’ll need to make au gratin potatoes

Let’s not overthink it, okay? You don’t need some fancy kitchen gadgets for cheesy au gratin potatoes – promise. Grab russet or Yukon Gold potatoes. Those just melt nicely into creamy bliss. You want them sliced not paper-thin, but not chunky either. Middle ground, like Goldilocks style. Cheese? Go for sharp cheddar and maybe a lil’ bit of gruyere if you’re feeling bold. Heavy cream or whole milk works, but honestly, heavy cream gets my vote for that top-notch creaminess. Toss some onions and a pinch of garlic in if you want them singin’ with flavor. Don’t forget salt and pepper, and bitty smidge of nutmeg for that wait, what is that flavor?! moment. A baking dish and oven, obviously, and you’re ready. Oh, and yes, you can use pre-shredded cheese if the holiday chaos is real, but hand-shredded melts like a five-star restaurant (just sayin’).

You can totally riff on the original using smoked cheese or even a touch of cayenne if you like a kick.

“Don’t tell my mother-in-law, but your au gratin potatoes recipe made our Thanksgiving last year. I barely had leftovers for breakfast.”

—Jessica L., actual carb enthusiast

What’s the difference between scalloped and au gratin potatoes?

Alright, people get this wrong all the time, so let’s set the record straight. Scalloped potatoes? They’re usually just sliced potatoes baked in a milk or cream sauce, sometimes with onions and seasoning. But cheesy au gratin potatoes? It’s all about the glorious cheese topping and cheese in the sauce itself. The potato slices are usually a bit thinner for au gratin. Oh, and there’s sometimes bread crumbs on top for that snappy golden crust.

Here’s the real deal – you might see some recipes blurring the lines, and that’s okay! The point is the cheese. If there’s no cheese bubbling on top and inside, you’re probably dealing with scalloped potatoes not au gratin. I once brought the wrong dish to a potluck and let’s just say, my foodie friend noticed. Still got eaten though. Those Heavenly Cheesy Scalloped Potatoes You’ll Want To Share are worth checking out if you want to make both at once.

How to make au gratin potatoes

So, step-by-step – here’s the foolproof way. First thing: preheat your oven. Nobody likes waiting for that clunky thing to heat up last minute. Slice up your potatoes (think about two to three per person if you want leftovers—everyone wants leftovers). Start layering them in your buttered dish. Don’t just throw them in or it cooks… weird.

Now, grab a saucepan. Toss in the butter, melt it, then onions (if you’re using), then stir in flour for a minute or two. This thickens stuff up. Pour in cream or milk slowly and whisk like you mean it. Don’t walk away. Let it get kinda thick, then add in handfuls of cheese, salt, pepper, a pinch of nutmeg (trust me on this), and keep stirring till it’s all melted. Pour that liquid gold over the potatoes. Top with more cheese. Bake until that top is bubbly and golden – sometimes it takes a little longer than you think, especially if you pile the potatoes high. Rest for ten minutes before diving in. (Yeah, it smells amazing, but molten cheese will burn your tongue off. Learned that the hard way.)

Tips for the best au gratin potatoes

Okay, I have made cheesy au gratin potatoes… more times than I’ll admit. Some came out, y’know, not amazing. Here’s where you avoid my rookie stumbles:

• Slice potatoes evenly, or you’ll get some crunchy ones and weird mushy bits
• Hand shred cheese for dreamier melt — don’t skip this if you can help it
• Taste the cream sauce before you pour it over the potatoes and up the salt if needed
• Cover with foil for the first half, then uncover so that cheese gets gorgeously brown

Pretty simple. Take these to your next family feast and brace for applause, trust me.

Ingredient	Amount	Notes
Russet or Yukon Gold Potatoes	2-3 per person	Thinly sliced for even cooking
Sharp Cheddar Cheese	2 cups	Freshly shredded for best melt
Heavy Cream	2 cups	Adds richness
Butter	4 tablespoons	For greasing pan and sauce
Salt and Pepper	To taste	Essential for flavor
Nutmeg	A pinch	For added depth of flavor

Can au gratin potatoes be made ahead of time?

Yes, and you should if you’re dealing with a busy meal like Thanksgiving or even a weeknight crowd. Here’s the real talk: cheesy au gratin potatoes hold up like champs in the fridge. Bake them fully, cool down, cover, then just reheat in the oven the next day. Splash a bit of milk or cream over the top if you’re worried they’ll dry out.

Honestly, I think the flavors get even better once they have time to hang out overnight. Perfect for prepping ahead and more time to make desserts or, let’s be honest, sit down and have that glass of wine you earned. There’s also a wild number of variations you can try – check out this Cheesy Potato Gratin Casserole for lots of inspo.

Common Questions

Should I peel the potatoes first?
You can. I usually do, but sometimes I leave the skins on for rustic vibes. Taste’s the same, really.

Does it freeze well?
Surprisingly, yes. Let them cool first, double-wrap, and freeze. Reheat gently so the texture isn’t funky.

Can I use a different cheese?
Absolutely. Sharp cheddar, gruyere, swiss, even a punchy pepper jack for a spicy twist.

Can I add meat?
Go wild. Chopped ham, crispy bacon, or leftover rotisserie chicken will all play nice here.

Any vegetarian swaps?
Totally. Stick with veg stock if you want or toss in mushrooms and spinach for extra bulk. Oh, and serve alongside Cheesy Ranch Chicken if you like mixing it up.

You’ll Regret Not Trying These Cheesy Au Gratin Potatoes

Here’s my not-so-subtle nudge… make cheesy au gratin potatoes part of your Thanksgiving or next Sunday dinner. You saw how simple it is. Extra creamy, cheesy, and honestly folks, nobody can resist that crispy golden top. While you’re here, you should also check out ideas for Easy Air Fryer Sausage Potatoes or explore something sweet like these Baked Nectarines With Cinnamon Honey Sauce. Go get cheesy, and let me know how it turns out for you!

Print