Deliciously Easy OREO DIRT CAKE You’ll Want to Make Today

OREO DIRT CAKE is hands down the one dessert that instantly takes me back to childhood parties. Ever been stuck picking between a quick treat or something everyone will actually eat? This recipe solves that headache! It’s so easy, yet tastes like something from a five-star restaurant (no joke). If you’re searching for something even more festive, those deliciously-easy-halloween-oreo-cake-bars-for-a-spooktacular-treat will totally fit the bill. Oh and if you want another spin on the classic, check out the deliciously-easy-oreo-dirt-dessert-to-make-today for more inspiration.

Dirt Cake Recipe: Ingredients & Substitutions

Okay, real talk. I’ve made this so many times I could do it in my sleep, but seriously I still peek at my bent recipe card (just to be safe). You only need super simple things. The best part? Most stuff is hanging out in your fridge or pantry already. Here’s what you’ll want:

1. Oreo cookies (a whole pack, yes really).
2. Instant vanilla pudding mix (chocolate’s fun too if that’s your jam).
3. Cold milk (don’t try almond milk here, trust me).
4. Whipped topping (Cool Whip or store-brand, no shame!).
5. Cream cheese (full fat for that dreamy taste).
6. Butter (just use what you’ve got).

If you need to swap, use chocolate pudding instead, or the reduced-fat cream cheese if that’s what’s calling your name. Gluten-free Oreos? Go for it. No Cool Whip in your store? You can whip heavy cream, but honestly, it’s more work than I ever wanted on a weeknight.

Want to see a happy crowd? Just put this on the table and folks will wander over without you even calling them. Seriously, every single time! And if your sweet tooth goes wild for stuff like this, you’ll probably obsess over this berrylicious-strawberry-crunch-cheese-cake too.

Ingredient Amount Notes
Oreo Cookies	1 pack (approximately 14.3 oz)	Regular or gluten-free
Instant Vanilla Pudding Mix	1 package (3.4 oz)	Chocolate flavor can be used
Cold Milk	2 cups	Whole milk recommended
Whipped Topping	8 oz	Cool Whip or similar
Cream Cheese	8 oz, softened	Full-fat for best flavor
Butter	1/2 cup, softened	Use what you have

How to Make Dirt Cake

Heads up, this part’s almost embarrassingly easy. Basically, you just layer everything and chill—nothing wild or difficult. Here’s the deal:

Start off by crushing the entire pack of Oreos. I usually toss ’em in a big zip-top bag and mash away with a rolling pin (kids love this part and will fight over it, just a warning). Now, mix up the instant pudding and milk in a large bowl until smooth and thick, then set that aside. Beat the cream cheese and softened butter together. This combo is honestly divine—you could sneak a little taste, I won’t tell.

Fold in your chilled whipped topping so everything’s nice and fluffy. Gently mix the pudding mixture in with the cream cheese stuff. Don’t overthink this—messy, lumpy, who cares? It all gets hidden under a mountain of Oreos anyway.

Now it’s showtime—start with a layer of crushed Oreos at the bottom of your dish. Spoon over half the pudding-y mixture. Add another layer of Oreos (save a good handful for the top though, it’s important for that full “dirt” effect). Finish with more filling and a heavy sprinkle of cookie crumbs. That last step? Magical. It looks sort of like a tiny garden, but one you actually want to eat.

Just chill the whole thing for about 2 hours. Overnight is fine, too, if you like planning ahead (I almost never do).

This is my favorite treat to take to family potlucks. People ask for the recipe every single time, seriously. Even picky eaters go back for seconds!

Best Oreo Dirt Cake Recipe (Dirt Pudding)

Here’s where I get really passionate (don’t judge). Some folks call this dirt pudding but either way, it’s basically heaven in a pan. The layers are creamy, chocolatey, nostalgic—it never fails to impress. Kids honestly believe they’re eating dessert straight out of the garden, and… maybe that sounds weird, but it’s why it’s fun!

I once made this for my birthday (yes, I picked my own cake as an adult), and not even a crumb survived. Use the regular Oreos—not double stuff, which is controversial, I know, but the cream part can make things a bit soggy. Every single bite is the perfect mix of cookie crunch and that melt-in-your-mouth cream cheese pudding blend.

If you’ve tried other versions, this one’s the most “retro” in my opinion. It never goes outta style. And honestly, the easiest thing to double for crowds or smaller get-togethers (it scales up or down so smoothly).

Don’t skip the last crumbly layer on top—that makes it dirt cake. Just trust me!

Store/Freeze

Here’s what I wish someone told me sooner: OREO DIRT CAKE will keep for about three days in the fridge. Just put some plastic wrap over the top, and try not to let it dry out. If your family isn’t like mine and doesn’t inhale it in two sittings, no problem.

Want to save leftovers for later? Just portion it in little airtight containers and pop it in the freezer. Defrost in the fridge (not on the counter, trust me, it’s a mess if you forget and let it sit out too long). The cookies will soften more, but you know what? Taste is still there—cold or creamy.

I never end up with much left, but in case you make two pans or hide a serving (don’t look at me like that), you’ve got options for saving every last bite.

Long Time Family Favorite

I think every family’s got one recipe they drag out for picnics, holidays, sleepovers—you name it. For us, it’s OREO DIRT CAKE. There’s something about the creamy layers and that chocolate crunch that just feels right.

The first time my cousin made it, we all stared at her like, “What is that supposed to be?” And right after the first taste, it became a required dish for every single party. Odd tradition—now we fight over who gets to scrape the bowl clean. Grandmas, toddlers, teenagers—doesn’t matter.

Funny thing, even folks who don’t “love sweets” (that’s wild to me) always help themselves. So yeah, it’s a staple, like cheesy potatoes or those delicious-apple-pie-cupcakes-thatll-warm-your-heart.

And if you’re on the hunt for new twists, maybe next time go wild with the deep-fried-strawberry-cheesecake-stuffed-wonton-bites? Sometimes you gotta shake up traditions!

Serving Suggestions

If you want to make this OREO DIRT CAKE even more fun, here’s a few easy serves:

1. Sprinkle extra crushed Oreos on top just before serving—a tiny mountain of them.
2. Top with gummy worms to really commit to the “dirt” theme (kids love this, grownups too if they’re honest).
3. Scoop into little cups for a grab-and-go party snack.

Common Questions

Can I make OREO DIRT CAKE ahead of time?

Absolutely! It actually gets better as it sits, so prepping it a day in advance works great.

Can you swap out the pudding flavor?

Yep! Chocolate gives it a really deep flavor. You can even try white chocolate for something kinda different.

Do I need a stand mixer?

No way. A simple hand mixer or some serious elbow grease and determination will do the trick.

Is this gluten-free?

Just use gluten-free sandwich cookies and the rest should be good.

Why is my OREO DIRT CAKE runny?

Usually, the pudding didn’t thicken—make sure the milk is cold, and don’t use the “instant” set method with warm milk.

You’ll Want to Make This Again (Trust Me)

So… if you’re still on the fence about making OREO DIRT CAKE, here’s the truth: it’s basically impossible to mess up, it vanishes from the fridge lightning fast, and it will make your family ask for seconds. A real-life five-star dessert for everyday folks! For lots more fun treats and ideas, try scrolling through this deliciously-simple-white-chocolate-halloween-oreo-bark-recipe or hunt for other genius snack hacks at deliciously-spooky-halloween-cake-ideas-youve-got-to-try.

You honestly won’t be able to resist going back for another spoonful—life’s too short not to. So go grab your Oreos. Treat yourself!

Print