Deliciously Irresistible: The Best Pecan Pie Cookies (Crumbl Copycat)

Pecan pie cookies are the answer for your “just one more bite” kind of dessert craving. You know how sometimes you want the special, gooey magic of pecan pie, but you’re actually not trying to commit to an entire slice? These cookies are it. I made a batch last weekend instead of my usual Heavenly Pecan Pie Brownies and… honestly, I had a hard time stepping away from the tray (just look at the evidence, my kitchen was a mess). If you love creative desserts like Deliciously Easy Pecan Pie Cheesecake, trust me, you need these in your baking rotation. Sticky, nutty, and way too easy to eat more than planned—get ready.

Why You Will Love This Recipe

I’m just gonna say it right off: pecan pie cookies are almost dangerously tasty. They give you that familiar, caramelized pecan pie flavor, but in a soft, shareable cookie shape that’s way easier to sneak into your lunchbox. Crumbl made them famous, but after making my own, I’m convinced homemade takes the trophy.

Honestly, they’re a crowd-pleaser for picky eaters, little kids, and suspicious adults (don’t ask me why, but sometimes people act weird about nuts—until these). The cookie base stays soft, which you know is a minor miracle with filled cookies. Plus, the topping gets all bubbly and golden, and the toasted pecans? Good luck saving any for the recipe, if you snack like me.

I gave a plate of these to my neighbor, and she “just stopped by” for my recipe the next morning. That’s the best compliment.

“These are the first cookies my husband grabbed a second helping of… before I even sat down! I loved how easy the recipe was to follow, and they really do taste just like tiny pecan pies.”

Expert Baking Tips for Pecan Pie Cookies

Okay, let’s get real (and a little picky), because the path to the best pecan pie cookies can get bumpy if you don’t pay attention. First, don’t skip toasting your pecans for a few minutes. I know it sounds like a skippable step, but it’s not. The flavor boosts about tenfold.

Chill your cookie dough! Warm dough will flatten too much and spread out. Just a 20-minute fridge nap does wonders. Making the classic “well” in the center for the filling? Use a rounded teaspoon. If you go wild with the filling, it’ll flood over the edges (I know from experience—messy).

For perfectly gooey centers, don’t overbake. They’ll look a smidge underdone in the middle—that’s perfect, trust me. Oh, and parchment paper will save your pans and make cookie transfer less… sticky.

Tip	Details
Toast Your Pecans	To enhance the nutty flavor, toast them for a few minutes before incorporating. This simple step boosts flavor significantly.
Chill the Dough	Refrigerate the dough for at least 20 minutes to prevent spreading. This helps maintain the cookie’s shape during baking.
Use Parchment Paper	Line your baking sheet with parchment paper to avoid sticking and make cleanup easier. Plus, it helps with even baking.
Perfect Bake Time	Remove cookies just before they look fully baked. They will continue to cook on the tray for a bit, maintaining that gooey center.
Storing Cookies	Store in an airtight container at room temperature for 3-4 days. For longer shelf life, freeze tightly wrapped cookies for several weeks.

Variations and Substitutions

Some days, you want to mix things up. Here’s what worked for me (and what didn’t… let’s just say not everything needs chocolate chips):

You can use walnuts, or try a mix of walnuts and pecans, for a different nutty taste if that’s what you’ve got in the cupboard. Out of corn syrup? A little maple syrup or honey works, though the flavor and texture change a bit (not worse, just “different” in the sweet department).

If you’re baking for someone who avoids gluten, a cup-for-cup gluten-free flour gets you close to the real deal (my aunt swears by it). Oh—don’t even talk to me about skipping the butter, but a good vegan butter does work for a dairy-free spin.

I tried a sprinkle of sea salt on top once (on a dare), and it actually punched up the flavor. So go wild, experiment, and let me know if you invent something even more irresistible.

How To Store and Pack the Cookies

You obviously want to keep your pecan pie cookies fresh, especially if you plan to gift them… or just sneak a couple over the week. So here’s the lowdown:

Keep them in an airtight container—on the counter if it’s not too hot, or pop them in the fridge if your house is warm. They’ll last around 3-4 days on the counter, a few more in the fridge. If you’re stacking cookies, place a sheet of wax paper between layers to stop them from sticking together. Want to freeze? They do great! Just wrap each cookie in plastic and then seal in a freezer bag. Thaw on the counter before serving.

I sometimes make a double batch, freeze half, and pat myself on the back every time I find one forgotten in the freezer. That’s a top-tier snack moment.

More Holiday Cookies

When it comes to baking for holidays (or really, whenever you want your kitchen to smell like a five-star bakery), don’t stop at just one kind of treat. Here’s what else I’ve been obsessed with lately:

• Deliciously Easy The Best Crumbl Pumpkin Pie Cookies Everyone Will Love: Like autumn in a bite. If you’re into pumpkin spice, don’t miss these.
• Baby Lemon Impossible Pies: Tiny, zesty, and zero fuss—seriously, my kid can almost make them.
• Decadent Creme Brulee Pie That Will Wow Your Guests: This one gets oohs and aahs at every family gathering.
• Pumpkin S’mores Cookies A Cozy Fall Treat to Enjoy: Chocolate, pumpkin, and gooey marshmallow? Perfection.

Common Questions

Do I have to use corn syrup in pecan pie cookies?
Nope! You can use honey or maple syrup, but it’ll taste a little different.

Can I freeze these cookies with the filling already inside?
Yes, just wrap them individually to keep the sticky topping from turning into a freezer mess.

How far in advance can I make pecan pie cookies?
They’re best within 3-4 days, but the flavor holds up for a week in the fridge.

My cookies are spreading too much. What’s wrong?
It’s usually warm dough. Pop it back in the fridge to chill out.

Can I use roasted, salted pecans for this?
Totally! Cut back a little on any extra salt in your dough, though.

Ready to Bake and Savor?

Honestly, pecan pie cookies pack all the delicious flavor of classic pie in one grab-and-go treat, and nobody will believe you made them at home. The secret is in keeping things simple, watching your dough temp, and not skimping on those crunchy pecans. Check out even more holiday pie goodness if you’re feeling ambitious or just want to try something new this season. Whatever you do, don’t wait for a holiday—pecan pie cookies are way too good for only once a year.

Print