Irresistible No Bake Peanut Butter Pie with Graham Cracker Crust!

Ever get that sudden, wild craving for dessert but realize your oven is already full? No Bake Peanut Butter Pie with Graham Cracker Crust is my bold solution for those “I need a treat and I need it now” kind of days. I mean, it’s so fast and easy, it rivals that berry quinoa summer salad with feta you keep making on repeat. This recipe doesn’t ask you to heat up the kitchen, but it does deliver shine-your-eye, five-star restaurant flavor. And honestly, if you’ve got peanut butter and graham crackers hanging out in your pantry (please tell me I’m not the only one), you’re halfway there. Plus, it holds up about as well at backyard BBQs as baked nectarines with cinnamon honey sauce. Embrace your sweet tooth. Nobody needs to know how little effort you spent on this.

How to Make Peanut Butter Pie

Here’s the beautiful part: this dessert, it’s impossible to mess up. Well, unless you confuse salt for sugar like my cousin did once (side note: do not recommend). First thing, grab a package of graham crackers. Bash them up—okay, don’t obliterate them, but make ‘em crumbly. Smush them into some melted butter until you get the kind of texture that just barely sticks together. Press it good into a pie plate. Chill it so it gets firm. Trust me, patience right here actually pays off.

Meanwhile, stir together creamy peanut butter, softened cream cheese, and powdered sugar till it’s smooth. You want it looking like thick frosting, but honestly, don’t eat it just yet (I mean, sneak a taste, everyone does). Fold in your whipped topping, then plop the whole shebang into that cool crust. Spread it out like you’re icing a cake. Now to the fridge again—let this pie chill for a few hours so it slices neat.

The first bite always reminds me why this dessert became my go-to “impress your neighbor” treat. Pure joy.

“I tried making this no bake peanut butter pie with graham cracker crust after losing a bet with my son. Never thought I’d love it this much! It was gone in two days—okay maybe one. Super easy directions too!” — Julie from Ohio

How to Use Whipped Cream Instead of Cool Whip

Alright, so not everyone likes Cool Whip. Can’t blame you—I get it. Sometimes you want that real-deal, homemade vibe. If you opt for whipped cream, you really just need heavy whipping cream and a little sugar. Don’t overthink it! Beat about 1 cup of cold cream with 2 tablespoons of sugar until it’s fluffy and holds nice peaks.

Then, gently fold it into your peanut butter and cream cheese mixture. Just blend carefully. No one wants soupy pie. Real whipped cream makes things extra-rich, almost festive, and sometimes I even think it tastes better—yep, I said it. Just don’t forget, fresh whipped cream means your pie should stay cold and might not last as long sitting out. Honestly though, in my house nobody gives pie a chance to sit that long anyway.

Ingredient	Amount	Notes
Graham Crackers	1.5 cups (crumbled)	Can substitute with vanilla wafers or chocolate cookies.
Creamy Peanut Butter	1 cup	Smooth variety preferred for texture.
Cream Cheese	8 oz (softened)	Full-fat preferred for best consistency.
Powdered Sugar	3/4 cup	Adjust sweetness to taste.
Whipped Cream	1 cup	Use Cool Whip or homemade, adjust for sweetness.
Butter	1/2 cup (melted)	Essential for crust binding.

Recipe Notes and Substitutions

If you don’t have the right stuff in the pantry, don’t worry. There’s a bunch of ways to swap things out and still win at pie.

• Out of Graham crackers? Use vanilla wafers or even crisp chocolate cookies.
• Don’t like cream cheese? Mascarpone was a fun (and rich) stand-in for me once.
• Crunchy peanut butter works just fine—gives the pie some character, actually.
• Want even more chocolate? Toss mini chips over the top.

When I made this with a honey graham crust, folks said it tasted like childhood backyards. Maybe they were right.

Ingredient Notes

A good pie starts with good ingredients (not to sound like your grandmother, but… it’s true). Creamy peanut butter tastes best to me—smooth is key for that dreamy texture. Full-fat cream cheese is non-negotiable. Trust me, low fat’s going to give you a runny filling, and nobody wants sad pie. Powdered sugar brings sweetness, and I sometimes add a splash of vanilla for more depth (don’t yell at me, purists).

Oh, and don’t skimp on the chilled time for the graham cracker crust. I tried a quick freeze once—eh, not as crisp. Room temperature whipped topping makes folding way easier, but if you go homemade, just be gentle.

How Long Will This Pie Keep?

Here’s some good news. No bake peanut butter pie with graham cracker crust keeps for about 4 days in the fridge. Longer and the crust gets a little soft, but if your house is like mine, it’ll vanish before then. Wrap it up tight with foil or pop it in a lidded container.

Nearly forgot: don’t let it sit out at room temp too long, especially if it’s hot out. Cream cheese and whipped toppings are not friends with heat. If you need to take it to a party, pack it in a cooler bag, and you’ll be the MVP of the potluck.

Common Questions

Can I freeze this pie?
Yep! Just wrap tight and freeze up to a month. Thaw in the fridge overnight, not on the counter.

Is it okay to use natural peanut butter?
You can, but it might separate a bit. Stir it really well first and expect a softer, almost mousse-like filling.

My crust fell apart when I served it. Why?
Usually means it needed more butter or more chill time. Next time, press firmer too.

Can I use sugar substitutes?
Absolutely. Just swap powdered sugar for your fave powdered sweetener. I liked Swerve best.

Any fun topping ideas?
Sure! Chocolate drizzle, chopped peanuts, whipped cream, or even strawberry cheesecake popsicles with no yogurt on the side for extra pizazz.

Your New Favorite Dessert Awaits

So there you have it. No bake peanut butter pie with graham cracker crust is basically foolproof, crazy-fast, and guaranteed to charm everyone who grabs a slice. Right up there with those easy no bake eclair cake recipe tricks, but in pie form. If all you want is a slice of creamy, peanut buttery joy with hardly any effort, this dessert’s waiting for you. Try it, and thank me later. If you need more inspiration for sides and salads, give those 20 minute rainbow quinoa salad ideas a peek too.

Print