Deliciously Fun Halloween Brookies to Satisfy Your Cravings

Halloween Brookies haunting your kitchen dreams too? You’re not alone. It seems like every October, I get that itch for something easy, chocolate-loaded, but just a bit more fun than basic brownies or cookies. If you’re hunting for a dessert that’s gonna wow the kids (or, honestly, just your hungry coworkers), this is it. And hey, while you’re plotting your sweets, check out these deliciously fun mummy brownies or maybe some pretzel spider webs—trust me, more ideas never hurt.

What is a brookie?

So let’s cut to the chase. What even is a brookie? Short version: it’s like a brownie and a cookie had a wild kitchen party and made the coolest, chewiest treat ever. You get that fudgy chocolate bottom, and then a soft cookie layer—sometimes chocolate chip, but honestly, any cookie dough will do if you’re in an experimental mood. The combo is dangerous. I always say, regular brownies are good, but these? They’re five-star restaurant level, except way more fun (and cheaper). Once you’ve tasted a batch, vanilla brownies kinda lose their jazz. Why choose, when you can smash both into one pan? My advice: don’t overthink it, just grab your favorite boxed mixes or homemade recipes and…you’re already halfway there.

How to make monster brookies

Alright, down to business. The way I make Halloween Brookies goes like this: I mix up a brownie batter (box or homemade, whatever’s in your pantry, I don’t judge) and spread it in the bottom of a greased pan. Then, I drop globs of cookie dough over the top—use your hands, get messy. You can kind of smoosh the dough to mostly cover the brownies, but leave some gaps for that cool brookie effect.

Now, here’s the Halloween magic—stick in monster eyeball candies, maybe toss on some bright sprinkles or candy corn. Whatever you’ve got rattling around after last year’s party. Bake the whole thing together. You get chewy edges, gooey centers, and bite after bite of Halloween perfection.

Pro tip: don’t stress if the layers don’t look perfect. Imperfection is sort of the Halloween spirit, right? (And hey, monsters are supposed to be a mess.)

If you’re looking for even more Halloween inspo, check out these rice krispie treat pumpkins. I mean… festive, right?

Tip	Description
Use Parchment Paper	Lining the pan makes removing the brookies a breeze and helps keep the edges from sticking.
Control Baking Time	Take them out when they look a little underbaked for that gooey texture in the center.
Add Fun Toppings	Monster eyeballs, sprinkles, and various candies will make your brookies visually exciting for Halloween.
Let Cool Before Cutting	This ensures cleaner cuts and a less messy presentation when serving or packing them.
Consider Gluten-Free Options	There are plenty of great gluten-free brownie and cookie mixes available for those with dietary restrictions.

Tips for baking soft and fudgy monster brookies

Oh man. If you want that real soft-and-gooey thing, here’s the playbook. Don’t bake these brookies all the way until they look dry in the pan. I mean it. They should look a touch underbaked in the middle when you pull them out. Trust your nose—if the edges look set but the middle jiggles just the tiniest bit, that’s the sweet spot.

If you’re adding crazy Halloween toppings, slap them on halfway through baking if you’re worried about melting, but honestly, the more melted, the scarier, right? Let them cool before slicing, or you’ll just get chocolate carnage (Not that anyone minds, at least in my house).

One last thing: parchment paper. This is what grandmas should’ve told us about brookies. It makes pan removal a dream, especially if you like big, chunky bars. Learn from my sticky disaster years ago—just do it.

“I tried this monster brookie recipe with my kids last Halloween. Easiest spooky treat we’ve ever made! The gooey centers won us over.” – Mary from Tennessee

Alternative cookie bar decorations

Maybe you’ve got picky eaters, or maybe the monster eyeballs didn’t make it to your Target cart (they always seem to sell out). You’ve got options, trust me.

I once used crushed-up Halloween Oreos over the cookie dough, which looked more impressive than it should have. M&Ms, ghoulish sprinkles, or little pretzel pieces give good crunch. If you want things looking next level, drizzle on some colored icing in wild zig-zags. Or, if you’re feeling the Martha Stewart vibes, press edible fake fangs or gummy worms halfway into the surface after baking.

Anything brightly colored adds Halloween flair, so don’t overthink it. Kids are going to eat them before you can even get a photo anyway.

Can this recipe be made gluten free?

I hear this question every year. Short answer: Yes! Just grab your favorite gluten free brownie mix and cookie dough. Most big brands have them now, so it’s not a wild goose chase like it used to be.

Swapping in gluten free flour for homemade doughs totally works, as long as you don’t overmix (otherwise it gets gummy—learned that the hard way). And if you can find gluten free monster candies? You’ll be the Halloween VIP in your group.

Oh—if you try it and love it, please come back here and share your tweaks! Last Halloween, my sister-in-law did a gluten free version, and half the kids literally didn’t even know.

Serving Suggestions

Your Halloween Brookies are ready—what now? Let me toss a few ideas your way:

• Serve them warm with a massive scoop of vanilla ice cream. Yes, it melts fast… but that’s kinda the point.
• Stack on a platter with a couple of those pastel Halloween bat wing brownies for a pop of unexpected color.
• Bag up cooled bars for party favor bags or trick-or-treaters who really earned it.

Trust me, you’ll look like you spent way more time (you didn’t). And if there’s one left over, it’s breakfast, right? No judgment.

Common Questions

Q: Can I make Halloween brookies ahead?
Yep. They taste just as good the next day and keep in an airtight container for about three days.

Q: Can I freeze them?
Definitely. Just cut into bars first, wrap tightly, and freeze for up to a month.

Q: What size pan works best?
I usually go with a 9×13, but if you want ‘em super thick and gooey, try an 8×8 instead.

Q: Do I have to make my own cookie dough?
No shame in pre-made dough! Both work great. Sometimes I even mix and match.

Q: Are there easy ways to make them less messy?
Let them cool completely before you cut. It’s hard, I know, but worth it if you want cleaner squares.

---

Ready for Spook-tacular Brookie Magic?

Halloween Brookies really solve that “brownie versus cookie” problem for good, especially when you want a treat that’s easy and wins over everybody, picky kids and sassy coworkers included. Mix up the decorations, try new candies, and don’t sweat the perfection. There’s something magical about a tray of Halloween Brookies that look a little wild. For even more inspiration, check out these spooktacular bat Oreo cookie balls or whip up a vampire bite trail mix for a full-on spooky spread. Alright, go make a batch—and send me a pic if you manage to snap one before they’re all gone.

Print