Delight in a Spooky Black Velvet Halloween Cake This Fall!

Spooky Black Velvet Halloween Cake is honestly the showstopper you need this year if your Halloween planning radar is a bit scattered (mine always is). You ever get that last-minute dessert panic—wanting to impress, but not wanting to babysit a cake all day? Well, same here, and that’s exactly why I keep landing on this super dramatic, dark chocolate cake. It’s the kind of treat everyone’s curious about and nobody ever leaves a crumb behind. Oh! And if you’re fishing for more Halloween baking inspo, peek at these deliciously spooky Halloween cake ideas or maybe try these absolutely irresistible black velvet cheesecake cookies—seriously, you’ll thank me later.

What Is Black Velvet Cake

So, what even is black velvet cake? You know red velvet, right? Well, black velvet is its mysterious, gothic cousin. It’s a soft, fluffy chocolate cake, but—not kidding—jet black thanks to a hefty scoop of Dutch process cocoa and a little black food coloring. It’s rich but not too heavy, sorta like chocolate cake that’s gone to a five-star Halloween party. Some folks get spooked thinking the color will taste weird. Promise it doesn’t! It just tastes decadent. The color is just a cool party trick for your eyes.

I’ve found kids go bonkers for this at any costume party. Adults, too. It’s also not as sweet as some holiday cakes, which I dig. A little cream cheese frosting on top? Pure bliss. I like how the colors pop, and you just can’t get the same vibe from anything else. Basically, if you want something bold (that’s somehow easy), this is the cake for you.

“I brought this black velvet cake to our neighborhood Halloween potluck, and even the folks who ‘don’t do cake’ came back for seconds. Super easy, super crowd-pleasing. A must every year!”

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

I’m not joking when I say this: you can make this cake in the same time it takes to watch one episode of Stranger Things (not the super-long final ones, okay). But speed aside, here’s what’s extra lovely:

• You get a stunningly deep black color with no fancy techniques.
• The cake stays moist for days (seriously, even hidden in the fridge).
• It’s bold enough for any Halloween spread but won’t weird out picky eaters.

One year, I added candy "eyes" on top and the kids pronounced it "freaky delicious." It’s always a winner.

Ingredient Substitutions

Okay, real talk—sometimes you open the pantry and realize, uh oh, you’re out of buttermilk. Or maybe you’re not feeling dairy. No biggie. Swap the buttermilk with a cup of milk plus a tablespoon of lemon juice or white vinegar. Boom, instant homemade buttermilk.

Dutch process cocoa is best for that super black color. But if you absolutely need to use regular cocoa—just know it’ll taste great, though it won’t be as dramatic. If you’re out of eggs, you can try flaxseed "eggs" (just Google it, trust me, it works in a pinch).

Don’t love cream cheese frosting? Use a dark chocolate buttercream instead. It’s Halloween. Mess around with the flavors and don’t stress it too much. The beauty of baking at home is doing whatever you want, right?

Expert Baking Tips

Alright, here’s where I spill the little secrets that’ll have people texting you for this recipe (no joke, happens to me every year). First, let your eggs and buttermilk hang out on the counter for 30 minutes. It makes the cake more tender. Second, don’t overmix your batter—just stir it enough until everything’s combined. If you go wild with the mixer, you’ll get a tough cake (boo). Also, black food gel is stronger than liquid dye, so go for the gel and you’ll need less.

Frosting tip: Chill your cake layers before swiping on the icing. It helps keep the crumbs stuck in place. And never skip lining your pans with parchment—trust me, nothing is sadder than half your cake stuck in the pan. Waste of chocolate! If you want to get fancy, sprinkle in some festive Halloween sprinkles or add candy bones for the giggles.

Last thing (promise): Taste your frosting before decorating. Some food colorings taste a bit… weird. Give it a taste, fix as needed before you frost your cake.

Tip	Details
Ingredient Swaps	Use milk + vinegar for buttermilk. Regular cocoa is fine but expect less black color.
Baking Temperature	Bake at 350°F (175°C) for even rising and moist texture.
Cooling Tips	Let layers cool in pans for 10 minutes, then transfer to racks to cool completely.
Frosting Choice	Cream cheese or dark chocolate buttercream works best.
Storage Options	Wrap in plastic and refrigerate for up to a week. Freezing is excellent for long-term storage.

Storing and Freezing

Here’s what’s wild: this cake gets even better after a day, if you wrap it up well and keep it in the fridge. Don’t ask me about the science, it’s just true. I use plastic wrap and then pop the whole thing in a cake carrier. If you need to keep it longer, freeze slices individually. Just wrap them tight and thaw overnight in the fridge.

Oh, and if you want to make it way ahead, bake the cake layers, cool, wrap, and freeze. Wait to frost ‘til just before serving—makes your life easy and your guests think you worked overtime. No one has to know.

Serving Suggestions

If you’ve got a table full of snacks, here’s how I like to serve up this cake, just to fit the mood:

• Top with candy eyeballs or gummy worms for max spooky vibes.
• Add a dramatic black or orange cake topper. Big impact, zero stress.
• Serve next to deliciously easy Halloween Oreo cake bars or maybe sinful bloody red velvet cheesecake for a whole dessert buffet.
• Leftover frosting? Pipe spooky swirls on brownies. Nothing goes to waste!

Common Questions

Can I make this cake ahead of time?
You sure can! I like baking the layers the night before. Just wrap and chill, then frost on party day.

What kind of food coloring works best?
Go for gel food dye every time. Liquid will never get as deep or as bold.

Is this cake only for Halloween?
Nope! Ditch the spooky decor and it’s perfect for any goth birthday or even a quirky anniversary.

How do I get my layers even?
I use a food scale or just eyeball it (honest). If one’s a little off, just trim with a serrated knife.

Can I double the recipe for a crowd?
Yes, totally. Works well in cupcakes too, just shorten the bake time.

Time to Bake Up Some Spooky Fun

Seriously, life’s too short for boring cake—especially in October! I hope you give this Spooky Black Velvet Halloween Cake a whirl (or at least let yourself get a little messy while you’re at it). If you find you want more creative, spooky treats, dive into ideas from BBC Good Food or just scroll through Pinterest and let your creepy creativity run wild. Easy, fun, a bit dramatic. What more can you ask for from a homemade Halloween cake? Happy (spooky) baking, friends!

Print