Deliciously Easy Apple Crisp Cheesecakes to Satisfy Your Cravings

Apple Crisp Cheesecakes. Just the name, right? It hits you with cozy vibes and that straight-up need for something sweet. If you’ve ever sat there at 10:30 pm, watching random people make desserts on TikTok and thinking: "Why can’t I make THAT at home?" yeah, I’ve been there too. I wanted something less fussy than a full cheesecake, but more exciting than plain old apple crisp. Enter these little apple crisp cheesecakes. Best of both worlds, if you ask me. These are way easier than you’d think, sort of like apple cinnamon french toast casserole recipe but with a creamy tang. You’ll be scraping the pan for crumbs. Oh, and if you love playing with toppings, try crispy stuff like these air fryer crispy fried onions in 5 easy steps as a savory-sweet twist. Anyway, let’s get right into it!

What is the best type of apple to use for apple crisp?

Alright, controversial opinion here, but not all apples are great for apple crisp cheesecakes. Yeah, I know–all apples are technically edible (unless you’re talking about my failed attempt with mushy Red Delicious once…big mistake). What you want is an apple that holds up under heat. Granny Smith is classic: tart, sturdy, and keeps a little bite, which means you don’t get a soggy topping. If you can’t find those, Honeycrisp or Braeburn work almost as well. They add just the right amount of sweet-tart punch.

Honestly, stay far away from the Red Delicious if you value texture. I used to think any apple would do, but I’m telling you, mushy apples equal sad cheesecakes. The contrast between creamy cheesecake, that crisp crumble, and juicy-but-solid apple slices? That’s what makes you go back for seconds…or thirds, you get it.

Oh! I nearly forgot, if you’re wild about fruit crisps, best nectarine crisp recipe and best peach crisp recipe will hit that same spot but with a summery vibe. Trust me, nothing beats it on a warm day.

“I always use Granny Smith for maximum flavor and crunch—makes the whole kitchen smell like I’ve got my life together!” – Jess, neighbor and apple enthusiast

Apple Variety	Flavor Profile	Best Uses	Notes
Granny Smith	Tart and crisp	Apple Crisp, Cheesecakes, Pies	Holds up well during baking
Honeycrisp	Sweet and juicy	Fresh Eating, Salads, Desserts	Popular for its flavor and texture
Braeburn	Balanced sweet and tart	Pies, Sauces, Apple Crisp	Good for storage; maintains texture
Jonagold	Sweet with a hint of tartness	Snacking, Baking, Sauces	Blends well in recipes due to sweetness

How to make Apple Crisp Cheesecake

Here’s where the magic happens, okay? It always surprises me how easy it is to make these. You just layer up the goodness, bake, and then have to practice patience while they cool (hardest part).

First, grab a muffin pan, unless you’re fancy and have those little cheesecake molds. Line it with cupcake liners.

Bottom layer: crushed graham crackers and a bit of melted butter. Mash it down flat. I use a shot glass to press it in—sounds weird, works amazing.

Mix up softened cream cheese with a scoop of sugar and a splash of vanilla. You want it smooth but don’t beat it to death.

Chop up your apples small—no giant chunks unless you want to bite into an apple chunk surprise. Toss with brown sugar, cinnamon, maybe a dash of lemon juice.

Layer spoonfuls of cream cheese mix, then apple mix, then sprinkle your oat-and-butter topping over everything.

Bake at 350F till the edges are set but the tops jiggle just a little. You don’t want to overbake (unless you like rubbery cheesecake, and you don’t, trust me).

Let them cool to room temp, then chill. Nobody likes gooey cheesecake.

Recipe Tips & Tricks

If you’re anything like me, you forget half the recipe steps on the first try. Here’s what I wish I’d known:

Room temp cream cheese = less lumps. Rustle it out early so it warms up.

Go heavy on the crumb topping. People always want more crunch.

Make ahead! These taste even better the next day. Seriously, flavors blend and everything gets all dreamy.

If you want more fall flavors, add a little nutmeg or swap in apple-pumpkin streusel muffin vibes for the topping. Or hey, stir in a spoonful of caramel dip from this deliciously easy caramel apple cheesecake dip recipe—that stuff is dangerous.

The best part? You don’t need fancy equipment. A mixer is nice, but a strong wrist and fork does the trick fine. My grandma would approve. I’m 90% sure she made more with forks than all the mixers put together.

“My friends didn’t even believe I made these myself—they thought I’d bought them at a five-star restaurant bakery.” – Tanya, long-time taste-tester

Why You Will Love This Easy Mini Cheesecake Recipe?

So let me just say it: Apple crisp cheesecakes are the dessert you’ll crave at weird hours. Because they just have that homey feeling – and still somehow taste like you spent $12 on a treat at a fancy coffee shop. You get creamy cheesecake, tangy apples, crispy oat topping… all in a tidy little package. Plus, clean-up’s a snap—these are single-serve, so no slicing messy cheesecake or fighting over the last crumb. If you like having personal desserts for parties or movie nights, you might get territorial over your own. Not even sorry.

Pull these out for a brunch, sneak one in to the movies, or just keep a stash in the fridge like I do. Minimal guilt, maximum satisfaction. Think grown-up after-school snack. These totally beat a granola bar any day.

What Are the Best Apples For Cheesecake?

It’s a toss-up between Granny Smith and Honeycrisp for me. Both have that sharp flavor that cuts through the sweetness of cheesecake, so every bite is balanced—no weirdly sweet bites poking through. Jonagold and Braeburn work if you want a more mellow, honey-like flavor. Again, don’t go with mealy apples. And for a wild turn, mix two types. The combo of tart and sweet is pretty next level. Sometimes, if I feel like mixing things up, I even add in a bit of the topping from my caramelized onion apple tart for little hints of savory magic.

Just whatever you choose, chop those apples nice and small. It makes them cook quick and they sort of melt into the layers instead of hogging the show. That’s what makes apple crisp cheesecakes different. Every bite is just right.

Common Questions

Can I use pre-made pie filling for the apples?
Absolutely, but fresh apples really taste brighter. Pie filling works if you’re in a pinch (I’ve done it). Just cut back on added sugar.

Do I have to bake mini apple crisp cheesecakes, or can I do this no-bake style?
You gotta bake them if you want that crunchy topping and set cheesecake. If you don’t care about crispness, go no-bake and just chill it.

Can I freeze these?
Yep, and they taste shockingly good frozen, like a cheesecake ice-cream bar. Wrap them tight in plastic first.

What other fruit could I swap in?
Peaches, for sure—or blackberries if you really want to get wild. Use that best peach crisp recipe trick and swap out the apples.

Why is my cheesecake filling runny?
Usually, it’s from not chilling enough or using low-fat cream cheese. Or, truthfully, sneaking bites before it sets. Hey, no judgment.

Give These Apple Crisp Cheesecakes a Spin!

If you’re stuck in a dessert rut, this recipe is the ultimate fix. Easy enough for a chill weekend but fancy enough to fool your friends into thinking you’re some kind of baking genius. There’s nothing stopping you now—unless it’s a too-small fridge. And hey, after you’ve perfected this, check out this apple cinnamon french toast casserole for a breakfast treat, or get inspired with reputable recipe resources like Sally’s Baking Addiction for more apple magic. You’ll want to make apple crisp cheesecakes on repeat, trust me!

Print