Delicious Sweet Potato Casserole with a Creamy Marshmallow Topping

Sweet Potato Casserole is one of those dishes I never thought I could make at home, you know? I used to think, “That’s a holiday-only, grandma-level skill.” Then, last year, I was determined to pull off a real five-star restaurant vibe in my own oven. Let’s be real: I wanted that creamy, melty marshmallow topping and a side of wow. If you’re craving something nostalgic that isn’t a ton of work, you’re in the right place. By the way, if you want to check out some other cozy sweet potato recipes, this delicious sweet potato casserole with marshmallows for everyone and this cheesy hamburger potato casserole are worth a peek, too.

How to Make Sweet Potato Casserole

Let me warn you, messing up sweet potato casserole? Basically impossible. I mean, unless you burn it to a crisp, but hey—that’s another story.

You’ll start with peeled and chunked sweet potatoes. Pop them in a big pot and boil them until you can stab them with a fork and they almost fall apart. Drain ‘em. Then comes the fun part: smashing. Get a little wild. Toss in plenty of butter, a splash of milk, brown sugar, some cinnamon if you’re feeling fancy, maybe a dash of vanilla. Just go for it. Whip it together until it’s creamy like you’d dream.

Spread that velvety goodness in a baking dish. Now, for the pièce de résistance—mini marshmallows. Cover every bit. Not up for marshmallows? Chill, we’ll get to topping options in a sec. Throw it in the oven at about 350 degrees for twenty minutes or until the marshmallows look like tiny toasted clouds.

I swear, every time I do this, people ask for seconds before their fork even hits the plate.

“My family asks for your sweet potato casserole every Thanksgiving. Honestly, I don’t even like sweet potatoes, but now I love them this way. The recipe is foolproof!” – Tina R.

Ingredient	Amount	Purpose
Sweet Potatoes	2 lbs	Base ingredient and provides sweetness
Butter	1/2 cup	Adds richness and flavor
Brown Sugar	1/2 cup	Enhances sweetness and depth
Milk	1/4 cup	Keeps the mixture creamy
Marshmallows	2 cups	Adds sweetness and creates a gooey topping

Can You Make Sweet Potato Casserole Ahead of Time?

Short answer? Thank goodness, yes. I do it almost every single holiday. Who wants to be fussing with boiling potatoes and sticky marshmallows the morning of a dinner? No one, trust me.

Just whip up the sweet potato part, spread it in the dish, and cover. Pop it in the fridge for up to two days. Add the marshmallows right before baking (or else they get weird and kind of…dissolve, yuck).

I’m not saying it’ll change your life, but wow, it takes the stress level down a notch. Makes cooking the big dinner way less wild. You can even freeze it, though the texture is better when made fresh-ish.

If meal prep is your jam, you might want to try this easy baked sweet potatoes with spinach and feta for another make-ahead winner.

Topping Options

Here’s the magic: sweet potato casserole isn’t just one thing. Want to get creative? Besides the classic marshmallow top, you can do:

• Pecan brown sugar crumble: Ooh, crunchy and sweet, a southern favorite
• Crushed graham crackers: Feels a little campfire-y, trust me, it rocks
• Toasted coconut flakes: If you want a surprise twist—make it tropical!
• Just butter and brown sugar: Keep it simple for the picky eaters

You can even mix and match. Half marshmallow, half pecan? Livin’ on the edge (okay, maybe just a little).

Variations

Sometimes I go rogue and switch up this dish. Ever swap in pumpkin for part of the sweet potato? It makes the flavor mellow and autumn-y. Or use honey instead of brown sugar—super cozy.

If you want to lighten it up, try replacing half the butter with Greek yogurt. And for a nutty kick, add chopped pecans on top before baking. That crunch is chef’s kiss.

Or get wild and stir in a pinch of nutmeg, allspice, or even some orange zest for a pop. Some folks even make a savory version with a sprinkle of cheese on top. If you’re interested in a different take, this cheesy potato gratin casserole is another crowd-pleaser.

You really can’t go wrong—unless you dump ketchup in it. Please don’t.

A Dessert-Like Holiday Side Dish

Sweet potato casserole walks the line between dessert and side dish, and I’m here for it. It’s that little bit of sweetness next to your turkey or roast, with a buttery richness you only let yourself have at special meals. Honestly, I think this classic side makes people happier than half the pies (just saying).

• Goes perfect with holiday ham or turkey
• Try pairing it with slow cooker vegetarian chili with sweet potatoes for a hearty meal
• Leftovers? Amazing heated up for breakfast with a splash of maple syrup

So, go ahead—treat it like dessert, eat it for dinner, snack on it cold. I won’t tell if you don’t.

Common Questions

How do you keep sweet potato casserole from being runny?
Just make sure to drain the potatoes well before mashing. Sometimes I let them sit in the colander a minute or two extra. Too much milk can be trouble, too.

Can you use canned sweet potatoes?
Absolutely. Drain them first, taste as you go, and skip some of the sugar since they’re already sweetened.

Is the topping supposed to go on right away?
Nope—add marshmallows after chilling if making in advance, and let them toast up at the last minute.

Can I halve the recipe for a smaller batch?
Sure! Works great in a loaf pan. Just check it a few minutes sooner.

Does it taste good leftover?
Honestly, sometimes even better. I think the flavors mellow out. Reheat gently and you’re golden.

Go Make This Sweet Potato Casserole Tonight

All in all, sweet potato casserole is way less complicated than it has any right to be. The creamy filling, the dreamy marshmallow topping—just unbeatable. I hope you dive in and give it a try, even if it’s not a holiday. If you’re itching for more casserole genius, peek at this cozy butternut squash casserole to warm your heart or even explore some expert tips for casseroles for variety. You’re gonna wow your crowd. Pinky promise.

Print