Best Gooey Pecan Upside Down Cake You’ll Love

Pecan Upside Down Cake is that fancy-sounding dessert you drool over at a potluck and wonder if it’s way outta your league to make. Spoiler alert, it’s honestly easier than you think! If you’re into gooey pecans, soft caramel cake bottoms (or is it the top?), and just a tumbling mess of luscious flavor…well, welcome home. You’ve probably tried your hand at other upside down cakes or gotten inspired after devouring that outrageous pecan pie cheesecake. Let’s shake things up and fix an easy, unforgettable Pecan Upside Down Cake today.

What Is An Upside Down Cake?

Okay, let’s just get this definition straight—upside down cake is just what it sounds like. You literally bake it “upside down” with some sort of sticky, sweet bottom that becomes your showstopper top when you flip it. It all started with pineapple back in the day, but let me tell ya, pecans totally steal the show. Imagine a buttery, sweet layer of caramelized pecans getting all toasted and glorious while your cake bakes gently above. Give her a flip and BOOM, dessert magic.

The real beauty? It’s rustic and perfectly imperfect. If things fall apart or stick a bit to the pan, honestly, who cares? Nobody’s judging because that gooey topping makes anyone forgive a little mess. Grandma in Oklahoma probably made one when she wanted to show off, but even your Uncle Dave could pull this off in a pinch. Just make sure you got enough napkins handy.

“I honestly wasn’t sure about flipping a whole cake, but this came out so pretty and gooey, and even the edges were everyone’s favorite. The recipe’s a keeper!”

Ingredients in Pecan Upside Down Cake

Alright, get ready to raid your pantry. Here’s what you’ll want on hand for a real deal Pecan Upside Down Cake:

• Butter – You want that rich, Southern goodness. Don’t skimp.
• Brown sugar – Brings the caramel vibes, trust me.
• Honey or corn syrup – Either works. That extra goo factor!
• Chopped pecans – Go for fresh ones if you can. Big or small pieces? Up to you.
• All-purpose flour – Nothing fancy.
• Baking powder and baking soda – For the rise.
• Salt – Just a pinch. Brings out the sweet flavors.
• Sugar – White or brown in the cake batter, your call.
• Eggs – For binding. Don’t use cold from the fridge, they blend better at room temp.
• Buttermilk or plain milk – Buttermilk makes it extra moist, if you’re searching for that “grandma made it” feeling.
• Vanilla extract – Don’t skip, it’s the secret fairy dust.

Substitutions? Absolutely. Swap honey for syrup, or toss in a swirl of bourbon (if the kids aren’t eating). Sometimes I even use cake mix (shh, don’t tell my Aunt Jean). Oh, and if you’re wild about pecans, this easy Southern pecan pie recipe is worth a look one day too.

Equipment Needed

No chef tricks, no weird gadgets—just the basics, friend. Here’s what you truly need:

You’ll want a solid 9-inch cake pan. Nothing too shallow or you’ll spill, and springform pans are tricky because the goo leaks out (man, learned that the hard way once). A big mixing bowl and some wooden spoon or hand mixer for the batter—unless you want an arm workout. Don’t skip a rubber spatula either because you’ll want every last bit of the caramel pecan madness from the bottom.

I always line my pan with parchment for less stick and a smooth flip. Seriously, nobody wants to scrape caramel off the pan with a knife in front of folks. Keep a wire cooling rack ready for flipping, plus a small saucepan for that topping. That’s it, nothing wild.

Trust me, if you’ve baked brownies before, you can handle this setup.

How to Make A Pecan Upside Down Cake At Home

Time to get your hands in the mix! I won’t throw fancy directions at you—just real talk:

Start by melting butter with brown sugar and honey (or syrup) in your small saucepan. Once those combine and get bubbly, stir in your chopped pecans. Pour this glorious mixture into your parchment-lined pan. It almost smells too good already.

Next, whip up your cake batter. Cream your butter and sugar together—don’t rush, five minutes is worth it. Add eggs one by one. Mix in your flour, salt, baking powder, and baking soda slowly, alternating with your buttermilk (or milk). Go easy so you don’t over-mix.

Pour batter gently over the pecan mixture. Try not to disturb your beautiful base—just smooth it out patiently. Bake at 350°F for about 35-40 minutes, or until a toothpick comes out almost clean. Sides might look a little crusty, but that’s the best part.

Let the cake cool for ten minutes (don’t rush this unless you want pecan mess flying everywhere—trust me). Flip it out onto your plate. Admire. Take a picture. Or, you know, dig in straight away while it’s warm.

“We made this after a holiday dinner and my mother-in-law still talks about how gooey and rich it was! Flipping the cake was surprisingly easy too.”

Tip	Details
Use Room Temperature Ingredients	This helps in achieving a smooth batter. Take eggs and milk out of the fridge about 30 minutes before baking.
Double the Recipe	If you have a large gathering, simply double the ingredients and use two pans.
Add Extra Nuts	For a crunchier texture, sprinkle additional chopped pecans on top of the batter before baking.
Experiment with Flavors	Try adding chocolate chips, or a hint of orange zest for a unique twist on the classic recipe.

How to Store Leftover Pecan Upside Down Cake

So if you actually have leftovers—sometimes my family attacks this so fast there’s barely a crumb—here’s how you stay safe.

Cover the cake with foil or plastic wrap (or shove it in an airtight container if you’re fancy). It’ll keep on the counter for one day, maybe two max. Longer than that? Pop it in the fridge! Just know the caramel will firm up a bit. A few seconds in the microwave brings back that gooey bakery-fresh vibe.

Really want to stretch it out? You can freeze slices. Wrap tightly with plastic, then foil. When you’re ready, thaw in the fridge and warm ’em up. Tastes just as outrageously good. Some even say better!

Serving Suggestions

Let’s get real. This is the star of any dessert table but want to level up? Try these ideas:

• Spoon a little vanilla ice cream on top. Melts right into the goo—YES, do it!
• Serve with a dollop of fresh whipped cream. Preferably extra cold.
• Add a dash of cinnamon or nutmeg right before serving to make it smell like a five-star restaurant.
• Feeling festive? Drizzle a thin line of caramel sauce across the top for those sticky-sweet vibes.

Heck, serve it for breakfast if you feel rebellious. No judgment here.

Common Questions

Can I use walnuts instead of pecans?
You can, but pecans give it the classic southern flavor. Walnuts are decent, in a pinch.

Why did my pecan topping stick to the pan?
If you skip parchment, that caramel sticks everywhere. Butter the pan well and line it—trust me, I’ve been there.

Can I double the recipe?
Absolutely, just use a bigger pan or two pans. Watch the baking time—it’ll probably take longer.

Does it have to be served warm?
Not technically, but it tastes way better. Reheat slices for the full gooey effect.

What if my cake is too thin or thick?
Pan size matters! Too big, it’ll spread and be flat. Too small, under-baked in the center. Stick with a 9-inch round if you can.

Ready to Get Baking? You Should Be!

Honestly, if you’re craving something like a big hug in cake form, the Pecan Upside Down Cake is where it’s at. The best part’s that caramel-pecan layer—seriously, nothing comes close. If you’re wild about dessert experiments, try my berrylicious strawberry crunch cheese cake or even track your treat’s nutrition with this calories in a piece of strawberry cheesecake guide. Go on, give this a whirl. If I can flip a gooey cake and make it look fancy, you can too—now, get that oven humming and make some sweet kitchen memories.

Print